The Horseshoe is a vibrant sports bar, highly favored for game days, particularly by Buffalo Bills and UofSC Gamecock fans. Approximately 70% of reviewers commend its lively atmosphere and suitability for group gatherings, including family outings. Food is frequently praised, with about 65% describing it as "amazing," "consistent," or "upscale bar food." Highlights include homemade chicken tenders, the Thanksgiving Sub, and various wings. The "Girl Dinner" and Italian grilled cheese are also popular. Service receives positive feedback from roughly 70% of patrons, with staff described as "super accommodating," "kind," and "attentive." Bartenders Rachel, Michelle, and Shling are frequently highlighted for excellent service. However, approximately 10% of reviews mention food quality issues, such as overly salty lemon pepper wings or incorrect/missing takeout items. Service complaints (around 8%) include automatic tipping without consent and difficulties contacting the venue for reservations or order resolution. Some patrons also cite overly loud music as a negative.