The Salty is frequently praised as a top-tier donut and coffee shop, valued for its creative flavors, fresh ingredients, and inviting atmosphere. It caters to those seeking unique sweet treats and high-quality coffee in a comfortable setting. Approximately 90% of reviews highlight the exceptional quality of the donuts, often described as moist, soft, and innovative. The signature Brown Butter donut is overwhelmingly recommended as a must-try, with many calling it the "best ever." Other popular items include the Churro, Key Lime, and Samoa donuts, alongside well-regarded savory kolaches. The cafe's ambiance receives positive feedback from over 95% of visitors, noting it as clean, comfortable, and spacious with a "fun vibe" and ample seating. Service is consistently rated as friendly, helpful, and welcoming by around 90% of patrons, with staff often providing excellent recommendations. While roughly 25% of reviewers find the donuts "pricey" (around $5 each), most deem them worth the cost for the quality. About 15% note some donuts can be overly sweet for their taste, and a smaller percentage (around 10%) experienced issues like blandness or donuts tasting "old." Weekend visits can lead to crowds and lines.