New Sitara Indian Cuisine & Bar is highly regarded for its authentic and flavorful Indian food, with over 90% of reviewers praising dishes as "delicious," "perfectly spiced," and a "masterpiece of flavor," often considering it a top local spot. The buffet is a significant highlight, with approximately 75% of related reviews commending its wide variety of vegetarian and non-vegetarian options, live stations for dosa, biryani, chaat, and pani puri, and consistent replenishment. Standout items include biryani, butter chicken, fresh naan, and goat curry, along with a good dessert selection. Service is consistently well-received by around 85% of guests, described as "quick and friendly," "attentive," and "caring." The atmosphere is generally noted as "open, spacious, clean," and "cozy," featuring modern decor. While largely positive, some isolated food complaints (10% of reviews) mention specific dishes being "over salty," "very thick," or "very spicy." A critical concern (4% of reviews) involves one report of a foreign object found in a takeout order. Other minor points include occasional buffet wait times or suggestions for clearer menu descriptions.