Fuego Celeste is widely praised for its high-quality beef, with about 85% of reviewers mentioning the "amazing" and "tender" steaks, and several highlighted the parrilla and Uruguayan authenticity. The service is highlighted by 80% of reviewers as excellent, with specific commendations for staff such as Franklin, Maria, and Jeferson, although there were occasional mentions of delays and errors in orders, usually during peak times. The venue’s ambiance, described by 60% as "nice" or reminiscent of Montevideo’s market, can get crowded and noisy, with several reviews noting a lack of air conditioning as a discomfort. 20% of reviewers felt the pricing was high, particularly for some individual dishes and the need to order separate sides, and a fraction noted an issue with "review begging" by the staff. Around 15% of reviewers expressed dissatisfaction with either the cooking of certain dishes, like overcooked baked potatoes or undercooked chicken, or the overall value concerning the experience and cost.