Café Paulin is appreciated by about 70% of reviewers for its traditional Argentine atmosphere and friendly service, often described as "cozy," "fun," and "unique." About 60% of reviews praise the food, especially the sandwiches and empanadas, calling them "tasty," "amazing," and "gorgeous," with recommendations for the Peceto Completo and El Patagónico sandwiches. 20% of reviewers report negative experiences, mentioning that some sandwiches are "bland" or "dry," and seats are "uncomfortable" with "limited space," often calling the venue "overrated" and "gimmicky." While atmosphere and service are generally lauded, around 25% of reviewers express concerns about the chaotic serving style, citing "gimmicky" service involving "sliding plates" and server errors. The café is often critiqued for being "overpriced," with some citing the high cost relative to the food quality, though about 10% of reviews highlight it as a worthwhile experience for its uniqueness.