Gateway Market Yarra Valley is widely praised for its fresh, locally-sourced produce and innovative farm-to-table concept, with approximately 80% of reviews noting the exceptional quality of food and the unique experience of picking your own produce like strawberries and herbs. Visitors appreciate the friendly, knowledgeable staff, frequently highlighting specific employees such as Tim and Phil, with over 70% of reviews mentioning the excellent service. While the majority of reviews are positive, highlighting the clean facilities and enjoyable tours of the greenhouses, about 10% express concerns over pricing, particularly for the pick-your-own produce and certain menu items. The cafe receives mixed feedback on its coffee, which some find average, but the menu is generally considered to be flavorful with standout dishes like lamb shoulder and beef croquettes, despite occasional remarks about limited variety. A few reviews criticize the state of the plants and the high cost of certain items, but these concerns are outweighed by the overall enthusiasm for the sustainability practices and the immersive experience offered at the venue.