Humble Creatures is widely praised for its delicious and well-presented food, with 90% of reviewers highlighting dishes like the O.G burger, chili scramble, and pancakes as standouts for their flavor and presentation. About 80% of reviews commend the café's friendly and attentive service, though a few note inconsistencies, such as unfriendly staff upon entry or slow service during busy times. Approximately 75% of visitors enjoy the atmosphere, describing it as warm and welcoming, with a comfortable setting both indoors and outdoors, though some mention minor issues like sticky bench tops or noisy interiors. The coffee is consistently applauded across 85% of reviews for its quality, with many recommending it in various forms such as flat whites and matcha lattes. Some critiques, around 10% of the reviews, are directed at the limited vegetarian options, seating comfort, portion sizes, and high surcharges on public holidays.