Gemini Melbourne is highly regarded for its lovely ambiance, thoughtful design, and a cozy, inviting atmosphere, with approximately 95% of reviews expressing admiration for these aspects. The food receives extensive praise in about 90% of reviews, with descriptions such as "phenomenal," "creative," and "delicious," particularly highlighted for its house-made dishes and unique offerings like the mushroom pate and anchovy selections. Service is another strong point, with around 85% of reviewers noting the staff's warmth, helpfulness, and attentiveness, though a small percentage (about 5%) mention feelings of being rushed or a less welcoming experience during busy times. The wine and drink selection are frequently commended in 80% of reviews, with mentions of the "thoughtful" wine list and exceptional cocktails enhancing the overall dining experience. Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, about 5% of reviews mention the venue’s tendency to feel slightly cramped during peak times, suggesting a slight detriment to its otherwise charming setting.