Holy Smoke Gourmet House Ferntree Gully BYO WINE & BEER receives predominantly positive reviews, with about 70% of customers praising the flavorful, tender meat, especially the brisket, which is frequently described as "juicy" and "smoked to perfection." The service is highlighted by around 65% of reviewers who commend the friendly and accommodating staff, further enhancing the dining experience. Some negative feedback, around 15%, focuses on specific items like dry cornbread and lackluster pork ribs, as well as occasional availability issues with menu items like beef ribs. A few isolated complaints, representing roughly 5% of reviews, express dissatisfaction with the cleanliness and food preparation standards, including hygiene concerns. Roughly 80% of reviewers appreciate the portion sizes, feeling that they offer good value for money, and enjoy the cozy, albeit small, atmosphere of the venue.