El Farolito Polanco is appreciated by about 85% of reviewers for its delicious tacos, particularly the al pastor, and authentic Mexican food; terms like "amazing," "flavorful," and "delicious" are frequently used. Around 80% of positive feedback highlights the ambiance and service, with mentions of a friendly staff and a clean environment, though some diners recommend sitting near the grill for a more engaging experience. However, approximately 10% of reviewers report issues with service speed, describing it as "slow," especially during late hours, while around 5% note dissatisfaction with certain food items like carnitas tacos described as "cold" and "spongy." Despite high praise for many dishes, a few reviews, about 15%, mention the price point as being high for the area, with one diner commenting on the absence of better alternative tacos nearby. Nearly 5% of reviews raise cleanliness concerns, with extreme cases of contamination being highlighted, contrasting sharply with the generally positive reception.