Straight Outta Brooklyn NYC Pizzeria
Brooklyn-style slices, crispy thin crust, lively local vibe
Aggregated Reviews
4.7
83 reviews
Review Summary
Straight Outta Brooklyn NYC Pizzeria receives high praise from roughly 80% of reviewers, who highlight its thin-crust pizza, fresh ingredients, and flavorful toppings, with descriptions such as "best pizza in town" and "high-quality."
The Margherita pizza and the Nutella calzone are frequently recommended, and Alex is often commended for his pizza-making skills, with many mentioning the accommodating and friendly service.
Approximately 15% of reviews mention delivery issues, specifically with third-party services like Uber Eats, noting the pizza sometimes arrives underwhelming and cold.
A small percentage of reviews, about 5%, criticize the pizza as inconsistent, either too greasy or lacking in toppings, and some customers mentioned unhelpful service during peak times or late hours.
Despite some minor issues, the overall atmosphere is positively described as a simple yet welcoming pizza joint that adds value to its neighborhood.
*This Review is an AI summary based on overall user ratings.
4.7
Food
Thin-crust pizzas with varied reviews; some praise freshness and flavor, others criticize inconsistency and lack of toppings. Noteworthy mention of the excellent Nutella calzone and sanpellagrano Pomegranate drink.
Location
Convenient, especially for those visiting Granville Island. Limited seating and parking options.
Service
Consistently friendly, welcoming staff; occasional reports of rudeness. Quick and accommodating service during busier times; exceptional customer care, with instances of complimentary offers.
Value for Money
Generally perceived as good value; some feel delivery charges are high. In-store prices for large slices seen as reasonable.
Vibe
Casual, standard pizza joint atmosphere. Notable for its clean and basic setting.