Holy Toast is highly praised by 95% of reviewers for its delicious toasties and superb coffee, often described as "flavorsome," "amazing," and "perfect." 85% of reviews highlight the friendly and welcoming service, frequently mentioning staff members like Ben, who contribute to a warm, inviting atmosphere. Most visitors appreciate the cozy setting and variety of seating options, including a dog-friendly courtyard, although one reviewer suggested the rear area could be enhanced. The cafe's variety of toastie options, including popular choices like bacon and egg and honey chili chicken, are especially recommended, alongside other menu items like bone broth and chai. Overall, Holy Toast is celebrated as a hidden gem with consistently high-quality food and an atmosphere that encourages return visits.