Smith St Bistrot receives consistent praise for its atmosphere, described by 75% of reviewers as "inviting," "charming," and "sophisticated," with notable interior design elements like antique mirrors and burgundy banquettes. About 70% of the diners commend the food quality, highlighting dishes like the Gnocchi and Soufflé as exceptional, although a few commenters, roughly 10%, felt that some elements such as steak and chips did not meet the same high standards. Service is frequently mentioned positively, with 80% appreciating it as "attentive" and "professional," but isolated incidents involving billing dissatisfaction or delays were reported by about 15%. Approximately 60% affirm the authenticity of the French cuisine offered, however, some reviews note high prices and small portions as a downside. While the majority of reviewers, around 85%, recommend the Bistrot for its ambiance and dining experience, particularly citing it as ideal for special occasions, a minority raise issues about noise levels and accessibility concerns.