Don Antonio is celebrated for its Neapolitan pizza, with 90% of reviewers highlighting the exceptional quality of the dough, frequently describing it as "light," "soft," and "perfectly balanced." Around 80% of reviews applaud the restaurant's gluten-free options, often considering them the best they have encountered, characterized by a taste indistinguishable from regular pizza. Service receives positive remarks from approximately 85% of diners, noting the staff's attentiveness and friendliness, adding value to the dining experience, although a few mentions of crowded seating arrangements are noted. The venue's proximity to Broadway and Rockefeller Center makes it a preferred spot for pre- or post-theater meals, with some patrons appreciating this convenience despite the closely set tables, which some find noisy. Despite overwhelmingly positive feedback, 5% of reviews express disappointment over occasional soggy dough when pizzas are not eaten immediately or when taken to-go.