Justine's on Hudson is celebrated as a "West Village gem," offering an intimate, elevated yet comfortable atmosphere ideal for date nights, celebrations, and regular visits. Its "classy, without being stuffy" decor and cozy interior are highlighted by approximately 90% of reviewers. About 95% of guests commend the food, described as "incredible," "phenomenal," and a "flavor explosion." The cuisine blends "upscale French bistro with a Filipino flair." Standout dishes include the crab risotto, pigs head croquettes, duck confit, crab omelet, and house-baked bread. The service receives unanimous praise from 100% of reviewers, described as "attentive," "friendly," "kind," and "5-star." Specific staff members are frequently mentioned for making guests feel "welcome" and providing personalized attention. The wine list is noted by over 80% of patrons for being "impressive," "innovative," and offering "amazing bottles that are off the beaten path," with expertise from the Rosenthal wine importers. Cocktails, like the Bloody Mary, also receive high praise. Minor criticisms, from roughly 15% of reviews, include some appetizers being "small" for the price, such as a $22 cheese plate, or main course portions being "too big." One review also points out "atrocious LED light bars" on the front door impacting the exterior ambiance.