Tavola Hells Kitchen
Italian Restaurant
Aggregated Reviews
4.3
424 reviews
Review Summary
Tavola Hells Kitchen is a classic Italian venue offering an authentic dining experience in a vintage setting. It is well-suited for those seeking traditional, well-crafted Italian dishes, appealing for both casual and special occasions.
The cuisine receives strong praise, with approximately 80% of positive reviews highlighting fresh ingredients and excellent execution. The wood-fired pizza, particularly the Margherita, is consistently lauded as delicious with a perfect crust. Pasta dishes, including Rigatoni Bolognese and Cacio e Pepe, are frequently recommended for their rich flavor.
Service is generally attentive and friendly, with around 70% of reviewers noting pleasant interactions. However, about 15% of reviews cite issues like rushed service, servers becoming upset if suggestions are declined, or misunderstandings, occasionally contributing to a "toxic service culture."
The atmosphere is often praised as warm, inviting, and intimate, with an old-school Italian diner feel. While many appreciate the cozy space, about 10% find it too loud or too dark for comfort. Pricing is noted as premium by some, and 20% gratuity is sometimes pre-added.
*This Review is an AI summary based on overall user ratings.
4.3
Food
Excellent wood-fired pizzas and flavorful pastas. Mixed reviews on other dishes: some dry seafood, tough steak, or pricey vegetarian options.
Location
Prime Hell's Kitchen spot, easy to find, walkable from Midtown.
Service
Mostly attentive and friendly. Some rushed, overwhelming, or rude staff; occasional unprofessionalism and management oversight concerns.
Value for Money
Generally fair pricing, though some dishes (kids pasta, bread) pricey. Premium point for some, variable portions, mandatory 20% gratuity.
Vibe
Cozy, warm, authentic old Italian trattoria feel. Can be loud and crowded, but with an intimate atmosphere for some.