Barbuto is highly regarded for its fantastic food and vibrant, spacious New American/Italian bistro atmosphere, often suited for groups. Many appreciate its open kitchen and, for some, good views. Approximately 85% of reviews laud the food quality. The signature Kale Salad is almost universally praised by 100% of those who order it, even by kale skeptics. The Jonathan Waxman roast chicken is celebrated by around 35% of reviewers as a "life-changing" must-order. Other favored dishes include focaccia, meatballs, and gnocchi, which receive generally positive remarks. Some guests, however, note mixed experiences with pizza (e.g., "bready") and other mains, with about 8% finding certain dishes underwhelming. While approximately 69% of guests commend the attentive and friendly service, a notable 12% report significant dissatisfaction due to order delays, forgotten dishes, or slow drink service, especially during peak hours. One review mentions a 'B' health rating concern.