Selecta Modern Pizza is highly praised for its exceptional pizza quality and use of fresh ingredients, with about 85% of reviewers labeling it as some of the best pizza in Berlin. The dough and crust are often described as digestible, fluffy, and a good blend between stone oven and Neapolitan styles. Approximately 80% of reviews highlight the friendly and attentive service, with staff members like Marco and Giovanni being specifically mentioned for their excellent hospitality. However, there are occasional complaints about slow or disorganized service and confusion over ingredient customization. Roughly 15% of reviews express dissatisfaction, primarily around instances of burnt pizza bases and mediocre wine offerings. The ambiance is commonly noted as cozy and welcoming, despite some mentioning cramped seating and noise levels due to children in the evenings. Pricing of pizzas is generally perceived as fair for the quality, and the availability of both classic and unique pizza varieties caters to diverse tastes.