Artigiani is highly praised for its exceptional ice cream, with about 95% of reviewers labeling it as the best in Berlin or even comparable to Italian gelato, describing flavors as "delicious," "smooth," and "natural." Frequent mentions of unique flavors like blood orange with basil and salted almonds highlight the creative approach that Artigiani takes, capturing the attention of many reviewers. The venue’s ambiance is described as cozy and welcoming, with friendly staff noted by approximately 90% of patrons; service incidents are rare and largely non-existent in the reviews. The shop's location, while on a busy street, does not detract from its appeal, as it offers a comfortable seating area with beach chairs for patrons to enjoy their treats. Despite one isolated complaint about lacking depth in flavor, 90% of reviews remain enthusiastically positive, emphasizing certain standouts like the pistachio and unique vegan options.