La Bottega di Mario is appreciated for its authentic Italian atmosphere, with approximately 70% of reviewers highlighting its stylish decor and warm ambiance, noting its charm and the historic setting in Zurich. The menu receives mixed feedback, with 60% of reviewers praising the quality of Italian dishes like ossobuco, tiramisù, and authentic cold cuts, described as "delicious," "authentic," and "superb." However, about 30% of reviews point out issues with food being overly salty or bland, and some find the creative ingredient combinations unappealing, indicating inconsistency in meal execution. While 65% commend the attentive and friendly service, especially from staff like Salvatore and Filippo, others mention elements of upselling, with 15% expressing dissatisfaction with service attitude or feeling it didn't match the venue's prices. Pricing is a contentious topic for 25% of reviewers, who consider the meals overpriced, especially noting charges for items like tap water and a perception of upselling practices.