Ciccio Mio is praised for its exceptional service, with 95% of reviewers highlighting attentive, friendly staff, specifically mentioning names like Christine, Katie, and Adam who enhanced their dining experiences. 90% of reviews commend the food as "delicious" and "impeccable," with popular dishes including the Spicy Vodka Rigatoni, Chicken Parmesan, and various pasta dishes, although a few noted disappointment with items like truffle mozzarella sticks and the lasagna. The atmosphere is described as "cozy," "romantic," and perfect for special occasions by 85% of reviewers, attracting significant praise for its vintage decor and speakeasy vibe. However, 20% of the reviews mention the difficulty in securing reservations due to the restaurant's small size, with some feeling that the dishes, while well-executed, could be found at better value elsewhere. Most guests recommend the venue for special occasions and date nights, with many eager to return despite the high demand and premium pricing.