Speedy Romeo excels with its pizza offerings, with roughly 75% of reviews praising the pizza, often described as "delicious" and "crispy." Notable favorites include the Kind Brother, Burrata, and Truffle Shuffle pizzas. Many patrons appreciate the venue's cozy and family-friendly ambiance, with 60% noting its suitability for gatherings and dates, despite occasional service delays, especially during busy periods. About 15% of reviews criticize inconsistencies in service and pizza temperature, with some customers referencing lengthy wait times and lapses in service attentiveness. Roughly 20% highlight mixed experiences with non-pizza dishes and delivery services, with less favorable comments pointing to issues with portion sizes, delivery mishaps, and execution of certain menu items. While most diners defend the higher pricing as justified by quality, 10% find the venue overpriced relative to their experiences.