Bacaro is praised by approximately 85% of reviewers for its authentic Italian cuisine, with standout dishes such as pasta, veal liver, and tiramisu frequently highlighted as delicious and high-quality. Ambiance is universally appreciated, with descriptors like "cozy," "welcoming," and "delightful" appearing often, while the central yet quiet location adds to its charm for many guests. Service receives mixed reviews: 80% of patrons enjoy the friendly and attentive staff, though about 10% mention issues like delayed service, inconsistent attention, and rudeness, especially during busy times or upstairs seating. While desserts receive some criticism, with 10% of diners finding them underwhelming or inedible, the overall food experience is highly recommended, and reservations are advised due to popularity. A few negative reviews, about 5%, cite concerns over air conditioning and noise levels, particularly in upstairs seating, but these seem minor compared to the positive feedback.