Comal Oculto is renowned for its exceptional Mexican cuisine, with 90% of reviews praising dishes like gorditas, flautas, and mole, often described as "fresh," "tasty," and "authentic." Favorites include the taco de chamorro and enmoladas, with several patrons declaring the mole and salsas as among the best they've had. Although 88% of contributors commend the friendly and attentive service, noting staff such as Georgina by name, 12% cite service issues, including handling of seating and occasional delays. The restaurant's intimate setting, with one communal table, is noted as both charming and challenging, with about 15% mentioning wait times and seating discomfort, particularly during peak hours. Prices are widely considered reasonable for the high quality provided, and while 7% of patrons express dissatisfaction, often due to long waits or perceived changes in experience over time, the overall sentiment remains very positive concerning the food and unique dining atmosphere.