Micklethwait Barbecue is celebrated for its high-quality meats and excellent service in an inviting outdoor setting, boasting a strong positive reception. Approximately 80% of reviews emphasize the meat, particularly the brisket, sausage, and lamb, as the standout features, described as "juicy," "flavorful," and "perfectly smoked." About 70% of patrons commend the side dishes, with the jalapeño cheese grits and mac and cheese frequently noted as exceptional and more memorable than the mains for some. The venue's ambiance, characterized by a pleasant outdoor seating area and live music, is highlighted in roughly 60% of reviews, although some mention issues with seating availability and long lines at busy times. Critical feedback, comprising around 20% of reviews, points to occasional inconsistency, particularly with the brisket and ribs being too dry or improperly seasoned, suggesting the food quality might vary by visit.