Emmer & Rye in Austin is known for its thoughtful Italian-inspired cuisine, with around 70% of reviews praising the innovative menu and standout dishes like the Johnny Cakes, Cacio e Pepe, and the pastas, frequently described as "delicious," "unique," and "crafted with care." Approximately 60% of reviewers commend the service, highlighting staff for being "friendly," "attentive," and "knowledgeable," though about 10% criticized service for being slow or inattentive during busy times. Ambiance is generally well-regarded, with descriptors like "inviting" and "relaxed," but a few reviewers found it noisy or underwhelming compared to the high dining expectations set by Michelin recognition. While 20% of reviews noted dissatisfaction, primarily with food complexity or pricing, the majority of guests found the quality justified the cost, with positive remarks about the focus on sustainability and locally sourced ingredients.