Penny is widely celebrated for its fresh seafood and vibrant flavor combinations, with around 95% of reviews praising dishes like the stuffed squid, ice box, and brioche bread as exceptional. Roughly 80% of reviewers commend the service, noting attentive staff, with specific mentions of friendly and knowledgeable servers, although some criticized the wine list offerings as limited by the glass. A recurring theme in about 70% of the reviews is the challenge of securing reservations due to high demand and limited seating at the all-bar setup, though many found wait times reasonable and the atmosphere worth the inconvenience. Around 60% of the reviews mention the restaurant's high prices, deeming it fitting for special occasions, and while some found it expensive, they acknowledged the seafood's quality justifies the cost. Approximately 85% described Penny as an ideal date spot due to its cozy ambiance, despite the premium prices and sometimes lengthy wait times for walk-ins.