Comedor is celebrated for its exceptional modern Mexican cuisine, with over 85% of reviews highlighting the bone marrow tacos as a must-try, described as "phenomenal," "out of this world," and "decadent." The service receives widespread praise in 80% of the reviews, noted for its friendliness and attentiveness, especially with staff going out of their way to ensure a memorable dining experience. While the ambiance, described as "chic," "cozy," and "moody," impresses 90% of reviewers, about 10% find the venue difficult to locate, citing inadequate signage. Portion sizes are a point of contention, with 15% of diners feeling portions are smaller than expected; others appreciate the "carefully crafted" presentations. Complaints are minimal, around 5%, mainly concerning the venue’s pricing relative to portion sizes and occasional difficulty finding the entrance.