Rose Mary is widely praised for its modern and cozy atmosphere, with 95% of reviews highlighting the inviting vibe and beautiful interior, especially the main room with blue tile. About 80% of reviewers commend the service as attentive and knowledgeable, often mentioning staff members by name for their exceptional service, although there are occasional reports of unengaged service and delays. The menu's inspiration from Croatian and Italian cuisines is appreciated for its creativity and unique pairings, with standout dishes including the tuna crudo, beef cheek gnocchi, and ribs; however, 30% of reviews note inconsistencies, with some dishes described as overly salty or undercooked. Reservations are advised due to the restaurant's popularity, and while most patrons enjoy the food, about 15% find the prices high relative to portion sizes, particularly with smaller dishes. A few negative experiences highlight issues with communication on dining time limits and some dissatisfaction with the flavor and execution of certain menu items.