Around 60% of reviews for Tyee Restaurant and Hotel praise the restaurant for its classic, hearty diner and bar food, with standout dishes like fish and chips, chicken fried steak, breakfast items, and friendly, attentive service from most staff, creating a homey, welcoming atmosphere; regulars describe it as a local, historic spot with fair prices and generous portions. Roughly 20% of reviews cite slow or inconsistent service, particularly during busy periods with limited staff, and occasional order mix-ups, but some guests note this is offset by staff effort and a relaxed vibe. About 30% of hotel stay reviews mention clean but basic or dated accommodations; some value the budget-friendly price and convenience, while others complain of poor cleanliness, missing amenities, hard beds, or safety concerns, particularly around housekeeping standards. Roughly 10–15% report highly negative experiences, including claims of perceived racism, rude staff, or neglected cleanliness, leading to guests feeling unwelcome or uncomfortable. The location is considered extremely convenient for Coupeville and nearby attractions.