Handlebar Barbecue & Brewery receives universal acclaim, with 100% of reviews rating it 5 stars and consistently calling it a "hidden gem," "amazing," and "must stop" in Queenstown, especially for brisket, pulled pork, ribs, bacon buns, and cinnamon rolls. Roughly 98% of reviews highlight the quality and flavor of the smoked meats, fresh-baked breads, and sides like cornbread and tater tots, with menu items often described as "the best," "delicious," and "well-priced," and drinks such as house-made beer and standout coffee also drawing rave feedback. Service is repeatedly referred to as "friendly," "kind," and "welcoming," with owner Jay and his team earning many personal mentions for their passion and hospitality—several reviews attribute much of the positive experience to their approach. Atmosphere is consistently called "relaxed," "casual," and "fun," and dog-friendliness, arcade games for kids, and good vibes are frequently noted; minor downsides include slightly limited parking and no mention of decaf coffee.