Around 90% of reviewers praise Horty Salteñería+Café for its authentic and flavorful Bolivian food, especially the salteñas, cuñapés, and other baked specialties, often calling them "delicious," "authentic," "outstanding," and comparing them favorably to those found in Bolivia. The café receives frequent compliments for its warm and friendly atmosphere, with personal mentions of staff like Doña Horty and her family; many note the service is quick and attentive. Coffee and typical drinks like mate de coca and chicha are described as high-quality and a highlight of the experience. Prices are generally considered fair or accessible, with specific praise for value compared to other cities. Around 8% of reviews mention drawbacks such as limited menu outside weekends, small or uncomfortable seating, salteñas being cold or small at times, or service lapses, with only 2–3% reporting poor experiences regarding quality or pricing.