Nearly 100% of reviewers rate One Eyed Jack very highly, frequently describing the Japanese food as "delicious," "fresh," "beautifully presented," and "full of flavor," with dishes like wagyu steak, tuna tartare, crispy rice, gyoza, and oysters singled out as standouts. The ambiance is widely praised (about 90% mention it), with words such as "cozy," "authentic," "stylish," and references to thoughtful Japanese decor, moody lighting, and special touches elevating the experience. Service is a universal highlight, with repeated commendations for attentive and friendly staff, and many guests noting staff by name for personalized recommendations and warm hospitality. Special event nights (like Taco Tuesdays and Wednesday wine promos) and reasonable pricing are mentioned positively, although one review notes smaller portion sizes as a mild drawback. No reviews mention significant negatives or disappointments; overall, the experience is described as memorable, with many stating it is among the best Japanese dining in Bali.