About 80% of reviewers praise Der Schafstall for its excellent cakes—often described as "amazing," "homemade," "big pieces," and with vegan options—and enjoy the beautiful setting, especially after hiking in the Lüneburger Heide. Roughly 70% mention friendly and accommodating staff, though about 30% criticize slow and sometimes chaotic service, particularly with inexperienced or overwhelmed waiters and long wait times during busy periods. The setting and ambience, both inside and in the garden, are repeatedly called "lovely," "quaint," and ideal for families and children, with many noting outdoor seating and proximity to scenic walks. While most food and drinks get positive feedback for taste and presentation, 15% of reviews voice concerns about brunch, breakfast quality, or high prices, and two reviews cite issues with food hygiene and flies. Events and activities, like cultural performances and kid-friendly spaces, are appreciated as extra perks.