Around 85% of reviews praise Olden House Cafe for its cozy, homey, and photogenic atmosphere, highlighting spacious indoor and outdoor seating, relaxing music, and large parking facilities. Desserts and cakes receive strong acclaim, with about 90% of reviewers mentioning the large selection and high quality, noting standouts like carrot cake, lemon cheesecake, red velvet, and Russian honey cake; only an occasional disappointment, such as tiramisu with generic cream, is noted. Coffee and drinks are generally rated as good to excellent, especially the matcha offerings and coffee lattes, but 10-15% mention small cup sizes and slightly higher prices compared to competitors. Service is described as helpful and welcoming by about 75% of guests, though a few report mixed or less enthusiastic staff vibes, especially during quieter hours. While the venue is often called suitable for working and remote meetings due to WiFi and plugs, one review notes it can be too noisy indoors for work or study unless seated outside.