Gasthof Hirsch is widely praised by around 85% of reviewers for its gourmet, creative cuisine, skilled use of local and regional ingredients, and expertly composed multi-course menus, which are frequently described as "exzellent," "Handwerk," and "ein Hochgenuss." Service receives consistent acclaim for being attentive, warm, and personal, notably with praise for the friendly hosts and knowledgeable staff, contributing to a welcoming yet elegant ambiance. The restaurant's compact food menu is explained and appreciated for its quality focus, while guests highlight a large beverage selection, including house-made gin and schnapps. Decor and atmosphere are described as cozy and comfortable, but a minority (about 10%) consider the interior or ambiance less warm or could imagine improvements; prices are frequently noted as elevated, but most agree the value matches the experience. Critical feedback (under 10%) mentions rare occasions where specific expectations, such as for special fish menus, were not fully met, or felt the service and ambiance could be more inviting, but these are exceptions against predominantly positive impressions. Reservations are strongly recommended, especially for weekends and special menus, and the venue has received recognition for sustainability—including a green Michelin star.