The Palmerston is widely recognized for its rustic and comfortable atmosphere, complemented by high-quality, flavorful food. It is often described as a vibrant neighborhood restaurant, well-suited for diverse dining occasions, from casual outings to date nights. Around 90% of reviews highlight exceptional food, frequently described as "sublime," "rustic," and "full of flavor." Recommended dishes include the pork ragu, goat, ox liver, and various pies. Desserts like malt ice cream and chocolate cake also receive praise. Ingredients are noted for being locally sourced and fresh. Service is generally praised by about 70% of diners for being "attentive," "professional," and "friendly." However, approximately 30% report issues, including "borderline rude" or inattentive staff, instances of servers reaching over guests, and lack of check-ins during meals. The atmosphere is highly appreciated by over 90% of patrons, described as a "gorgeous," "warm bistro" or "date spot." Some note it can be "a bit noisy" or "hot." "Imaginative cocktails" and local craft beers are positively highlighted. Roughly 15% of reviewers found set lunch menu portions small for the price or felt the overall experience was "overpriced" when service issues arose.