Simmer Down is praised for its pizza and vibrant atmosphere, a popular choice for dining. It is noted for "exotic" and "gourmet" pizzas, with "lomito al maitre" also receiving high praise. About 80% of reviewers commend the pizza for "thin dough," "cheesy" quality, and "great toppings." Popular options include Loroco cheese and Maradona pizzas. Steaks are also frequently recommended. Service feedback is mixed. 60% highlight "super friendly" and "attentive" staff. However, around 25% report "extremely slow" service, with wait times up to "an hour for food" or "30 minutes for drinks," and order issues. Over 90% of visitors consistently praise the "great atmosphere" and "good vibes," noting a "comfortable" and "pet-friendly" environment. Live music and events are a significant attraction. Valet parking is offered; 15% mention limited parking. About 10% of reviewers raise specific concerns, including "dirty tables," "raw chicken chunks" that were re-served, and "vegetarian pizza with meat in the sauce." Item unavailability and amenity problems are also cited.