Buffalo State Pizza Co. is highly praised for its New York-style pizza, generous portions, and lively atmosphere. Approximately 90% of reviews call the pizza delicious, high-quality, and a top choice in the area, often noting its massive slices. The crust is a frequent highlight for about 30% of diners, described as phenomenal, crispy, and well-cooked. Toppings are praised as plentiful and fresh by 25%. Recommended items include the Don Pepe and Pesto Pete pizzas, plus the "fully clothed" garlic bread and breadsticks. The new location earns significant positive feedback (35%), lauded as fantastic, spacious, and boasting a "cool vibe" with a good bar and live music. Service is generally found friendly and efficient by 25%, with staff often noted for attentiveness. Conversely, around 15% of reviews mention pizza cooking inconsistencies, from burnt to undercooked crusts. Some customers (10%) consider pricing high, and another 10% cite staff issues like inattentiveness or unclear communication. Minor complaints include long waits or uncomfortable temperatures.